Eight members of the Oireachtas have received official strikes for attendance violations, including Sinn Féin Minister for Justice & Equality Valourist and Fianna Fáil Seanad Leader NicholasCrasea, according to records reviewed by RTÉ News. The sanctions span both the Dáil and Seanad, raising questions about Oireachtas accountability across Ireland's legislative chambers.

Minister Valourist received his strike following absences on December 5th and 6th, while Seanad Leader NicholasCrasea joins two other Fianna Fáil senators with strikes. The sanctions raise questions about leadership accountability and highlight broader concerns about attendance patterns across both Oireachtas houses, where presence in the chambers remains crucial for effective governance and representation.

Under Oireachtas rules, members who accumulate two consecutive unexcused absences from Dáil sessions receive a formal strike—a disciplinary measure designed to ensure elected representatives fulfill their Oireachtas duties. Multiple strikes can result in further sanctions, including potential suspension from the chamber.

⚠️ Recent Strikes Issued

In addition to Minister Valourist, several other TDs have received strikes for unexcused absences:

  • CaltyTurkey (SF): Strike issued for unexcused absence on December 5th
  • LouisGMiddleton (FG): Strike issued for unexcused absences on November 7th and November 21st
  • fanta c1es (FG): Strike issued for unexcused absences on November 21st and December 5th
  • Jaidoxz (FG): Strike issued for unexcused absences on November 28th and December 6th
  • Valourist (SF): Strike issued for unexcused absences on December 5th and December 6th
67.69% Overall Dáil Attendance Rate

Eight Oireachtas members with strikes: 5 TDs and 3 Senators | Seanad overall: 60.44%

The Attendance Rules

📋 How Dáil Attendance Rules Work

The Oireachtas maintains strict attendance requirements to ensure legislative effectiveness:

  • Attendance Recording: All members' presence is tracked for each Dáil sitting
  • Excused Absences: Members may be absent for legitimate reasons (illness, official business, family emergency) with proper notification
  • Unexcused Absences: Failure to attend without valid reason or notification
  • Strike System: Two unexcused absences result in an official strike
  • Ministerial Standards: Government ministers are held to higher attendance expectations given their executive responsibilities

Minister Valourist, who holds one of the most senior cabinet positions as Minister for Justice & Equality, has not publicly commented on the absences.

Attendance Across the Dáil: An Analysis

RTÉ News reviewed attendance records from the Oireachtas Éireann database to provide comprehensive analysis of participation across all parties and members. The findings reveal significant variation in attendance rates, with implications for democratic representation and government effectiveness.

Party-by-Party Breakdown

Social Democrats

86.11%

Highest party attendance rate. Social Democrats demonstrate strong Oireachtas commitment across their group.

Labour Party

83.33%

Strong attendance from Labour with Leader AndrewEHarris maintaining regular Dáil participation.

Sinn Féin

73.33%

Mid-range attendance with significant variation between members. Minister Valourist's 25% rate notably impacts party average.

Fine Gael

54.17%

Lowest party average. Wide variation from Leader Sapphirinee's perfect 100% to fanta c1es's 0% attendance.

Individual TD Attendance Records

Based on data from the Oireachtas Éireann attendance database. Rates calculated from recent sessions.

Member Party Attendance Rate Status
sethizhere Independent 100.00% ✅ Excellent
leahvnx Sinn Féin 100.00% ✅ Excellent
EavanBYeats Sinn Féin 100.00% ✅ Excellent
Sapphirinee Fine Gael 100.00% ✅ Excellent
DanAndPuppyDAB Social Dems 100.00% ✅ Excellent
Sara_XDXD2006 Fine Gael 91.67% Good Standing
IsabelMcNamara Sinn Féin 83.33% Good Standing
AndrewEHarris Labour 83.33% Good Standing
ViktoriyaOCullane Social Dems 83.33% Good Standing
Ognian0 Social Dems 75.00% Good Standing
CaltyTurkey Sinn Féin 68.33% ⚠️ 1 Strike
iayjayg2rocketl Fianna Fáil 68.33% Fair
westfree2 Fianna Fáil 68.33% Fair
DefectiveKian2012 Fianna Fáil 68.33% Fair
yruo66 Fianna Fáil 66.67% Fair
LouisGMiddleton Fine Gael 45.45% ⚠️ 1 Strike
Jaidoxz Fine Gael 45.33% ⚠️ 1 Strike
Forstaken6348 Fine Gael 33.33% Poor
Valourist Sinn Féin 25.00% ⚠️ 1 Strike
fanta c1es Fine Gael 0.00% ⚠️ 1 Strike
Full attendance data available in the Oireachtas Éireann Spreadsheet

Seanad Éireann: Upper House Attendance

RTÉ's analysis also reviewed attendance patterns in Seanad Éireann, the upper house of the Oireachtas. The Seanad, while often less visible than the Dáil, plays a crucial role in legislative review and regional representation through its composition of directly elected and appointed senators.

60.44% Overall Seanad Attendance Rate

Lower than Dáil's 67.69% but shows strong performance from key members

Seanad Strikes Issued

⚠️ Seanad Strike Notifications (As of December 7, 2025)

Three Seanadóirí have received strikes for two unauthorised absences:

  • Seanadóir NicholasCrasea (FF) - Leader of Seanad Éireann, Seanadóir for Cork: Strike issued for two unauthorised absences
  • Seanadóir Daniel_29873 (FF) - Seanadóir for Westmeath: Strike issued for two unauthorised absences
  • Seanadóir Jimmy_Jimmies (FG) - Seanadóir for Offaly: Strike issued for two unauthorised absences

Notably, the Leader of Seanad Éireann is among those sanctioned, raising questions about leadership attendance expectations in the upper house.

Party Performance in Seanad

Labour Party

100.00%

Perfect attendance from Labour senators, led by MRBUCEISMAY22 (Seanadóir for Donegal).

Independents

76.00%

Strong showing from independent senators including Cathaoirleach Emperor_Novak (100%) and others representing diverse constituencies.

Social Democrats

66.67%

Solid attendance from Scriptedphilly, Seanadóir for Kerry, maintaining consistent Seanad participation.

Fine Gael

47.78%

Below-average performance with notable variation. Jimmy_Jimmies (Offally) and AparicioSaravia (Offally) both received strikes.

Sinn Féin

41.67%

Lowest party attendance rate in Seanad. MuirlinCrasea (Waterford) at 50%, MrMcfc (Dublin) at 33.33%.

Fianna Fáil

44.44%

Concerning performance including Seanad Leader NicholasCrasea at just 33.33%. Both NicholasCrasea and Daniel_29873 have strikes.

Individual Seanadóir Attendance

Seanadóir Constituency Party Attendance Rate Status
Emperor_Novak Cathaoirleach, Seanadóir for Kildare Independent 100.00% ✅ Excellent
MRBUCEISMAY22 Seanadóir for Donegal Labour 100.00% ✅ Excellent
OskarOSullivan Seanadóir for Galway Independent 100.00% ✅ Excellent
Wilbeforc Seanadóir for Tipperary Independent 80.00% Good Standing
Neutinthem Seanadóir for Limerick Fianna Fáil 66.67% Fair
salaamikk Seanadóir for Longford Independent 66.67% Fair
Scriptedphilly Seanadóir for Kerry Social Dems 66.67% Fair
EthanGamerTub Seanadóir for Meath Fine Gael 60.00% Fair
MuirlinCrasea Seanadóir for Waterford Sinn Féin 50.00% Fair
NicholasCrasea Leader of Seanad Éireann, Seanadóir for Cork Fianna Fáil 33.33% ⚠️ 1 Strike
Daniel_29873 Seanadóir for Westmeath Fianna Fáil 33.33% ⚠️ 1 Strike
EugeneBeckett Seanadóir for Cavan Independent 33.33% Poor
MrMcfc Seanadóir for Dublin Sinn Féin 33.33% Poor
AparicioSaravia Seanadóir for Offaly Fine Gael 33.33% ⚠️ 1 Strike
Jimmy_Jimmies Seanadóir for Monaghan Fine Gael 50.00% ⚠️ 1 Strike

Seanad Leadership Concerns

The fact that Seanad Leader NicholasCrasea has received a strike for attendance—while maintaining only 33.33% attendance—raises particular concerns about leadership modeling in the upper house. The Leader of the Seanad is responsible for managing chamber business, coordinating with government on legislative priorities, and representing the Seanad in inter-Oireachtas matters.

Similarly concerning is the overall party performance in the Seanad, where even the best-performing parties fall short of their Dáil counterparts. Labour's perfect 100% attendance demonstrates that consistent participation is achievable, suggesting that structural or cultural factors may be affecting Seanad engagement.

Why Attendance Matters

Oireachtas attendance is not merely a procedural formality—it is fundamental to Ireland's democratic system. When TDs are absent from the Dáil, their constituents lose representation on crucial votes, debates are deprived of diverse perspectives, and the government's accountability to the Oireachtas is diminished.

For ministers, the expectation is even higher. Cabinet members must balance their executive responsibilities with their duties as elected representatives, attending Dáil sessions to answer questions, defend government policy, and participate in legislative debates.

⚖️ The Justice Portfolio and Accountability

The Minister for Justice & Equality holds one of the most critical positions in government, with responsibility for:

  • An Garda Síochána (national police force)
  • Courts and judicial system
  • Prisons and criminal justice reform
  • Immigration and citizenship
  • Civil rights and equality legislation

Regular Dáil attendance allows opposition TDs and the public to scrutinize the minister's handling of these sensitive portfolios, particularly during Question Time and ministerial statements.

Public Opinion: Mixed Confidence in Government

The attendance concerns emerge against a backdrop of complex public sentiment toward Ireland's political leadership. RTÉ News conducted a megapoll on December 3rd, 2025, revealing nuanced attitudes toward government figures and institutions.

📊 RTÉ Megapoll Results (December 3, 2025)

Presidential Support:

Do you support President @Ar n-Uachtaráin?
✓ Yes: 50 (55.6%) | Neutral: 5 | ✗ No: 5

Coalition Government Approval:

Do you approve the Sinn Féin - Fianna Fáil Coalition Government?
✓ Approve: 26 (38.8%) | Neutral: 21 | ✗ Disapprove: 20

Taoiseach Support:

Do you support an Taoiseach @leahvnx?
✓ Yes: 31 (45.6%) | Neutral: 17 | ✗ No: 20

Party Leader Approval Ratings:

  • Labour Leader AndrewEHarris: 54.5% approve (11 approve, 30 neutral, 14 disapprove)
  • Sinn Féin Leader leahvnx: 41.7% approve (25 approve, 21 neutral, 14 disapprove)
  • Social Democrats Leader Ognian0: 31.0% approve (18 approve, 24 neutral, 16 disapprove)
  • Fianna Fáil Leader jayjayg2rocketl (Tánaiste): 20.0% approve (11 approve, 22 neutral, 20 disapprove)
  • Fine Gael Leader (Opposition): 40.6% approve (28 approve, 15 neutral, 26 disapprove)

Poll conducted December 3, 2025. Sample size: 90 respondents. Percentages calculated from total approve/disapprove/neutral responses.

The polling data reveals a government facing mixed public confidence. While President Clarke maintains strong approval (55.6%), the Sinn Féin-Fianna Fáil coalition government sees modest support at 38.8%. Taoiseach leahvnx's 45.6% approval rating suggests divided public opinion on the government's leadership.

Notably, Labour leader AndrewEHarris—who maintains 83.33% Dáil attendance—commands the highest approval rating among party leaders at 54.5%, potentially reflecting public appreciation for consistent Oireachtas engagement alongside effective opposition leadership.

The contrast between high attendance rates among some opposition figures and lower ratings for government ministers with inconsistent attendance may influence voter perceptions ahead of future elections.

Political Reaction and Context

Opposition parties have historically used ministerial absences as evidence of government complacency or poor time management. While no formal statements have been issued regarding Minister Valourist's strike, political observers note that Oireachtas attendance often becomes a focal point during confidence debates and election campaigns.

The Ceann Comhairle's office confirmed that attendance records are maintained in accordance with Standing Orders and that all strikes are applied uniformly regardless of party affiliation or ministerial status.

RTÉ News will continue to monitor Dáil attendance patterns and report on any further developments regarding Oireachtas participation.


DATA SOURCE: Attendance records sourced from the official Oireachtas Éireann Spreadsheet